iTunes & App Store

Read Everything That Dunks Must Converge

Read Everything That Dunks Must Converge
by Bryan Harvey

Truth & lies in Pixar's 'The Good Dinosaur'

Truth & lies in Pixar's 'The Good Dinosaur'
by Bryan Harvey

A world of child soldiers & cowboys

A world of child soldiers & cowboys
by Bryan Harvey

To their own devices: Pablo Larrain's 'The Club'

To their own devices: Pablo Larrain's 'The Club'
by Bryan Harvey
Showing posts with label Point/Counterpoint. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Point/Counterpoint. Show all posts

Point/Counterpoint: Rick Reilly's "Pay for Play"

July 16, 2011


This is our column where we wrangle every nonsensical statement a writer proclaims in their commentary. Next up is Rick Reilly of ESPN, taken from the article "Pay for Play."


For the 116th straight season, it looks as if American golf is going to get through another year without a labor stoppage. Arnold Palmers for everybody.


Not true in the NFL and the NBA -- both are in lockouts now -- but how we don't have one in golf I'll ever know. If anybody should strike, it's golfers. They have the worst deal since the Winklevoss twins met Mark Zuckerberg.

Point / Counterpoint: Ken Rosenthal's NLCS Preview

October 15, 2009

This is our column where we wrangle every nonsensical statement a writer proclaims in their commentary. Next up is Ken Rosenthal of Fox Sports, taken from the article titled "NLCS preview: Phillies starting to look like '08 team"

Before the postseason began, I wrote, "If the Phillies were the Phillies of May or even July, I would pick them not only to beat the Rockies, but also to win their second straight World Series."


I then picked the Rockies in five games, contending that the Phillies had too many issues — questionable starting pitching, a bullpen in disarray, an offense that had lost some of its edge.

So you got that series incredibly wrong, why should we trust you now?

Those issues remain, to varying degrees, but I'm again sold. The Phillies started to regain their mojo in their four-game triumph over the Rockies, and I don't see them turning back.

Four games changed your mind about the Phillies? I'm guessing you're the type of guy who decided to marry your wife the moment you met her. Then after realizing she laughs too much, you called the wedding off, only to notice that she was only laughing to make you feel better about your unappreciated dick jokes at her family reunion.

The Phillies need more out of Cole Hamels, more out of Jimmy Rollins, continued improvement out of Brad Lidge. But if they play at close to their peak, the Dodgers cannot stop them.

Agreed. If Hamels, Rollins and Lidge play at the peak of their games they will be unstoppable. But why would anyone expect that now? Rollins is coming off one of the worsts seasons of his career and Lidge was terribly inconsistent, not to mention both stunk it up against the Dodgers in 2009. (Rollins hit under .200 against them and Lidge allowed eight hits and had a 7.36 ERA in 3 2/3 innings.)

The Dodgers will be formidable in the NLCS, more formidable than they were a year ago when they started five straight right-handers against a team that featured two left-handed sluggers — Chase Utley and Ryan Howard — and has since added a third, Raul Ibanez.

This time, the Dodgers are in better position to neutralize the Phillies' left-handed power. Lefties Randy Wolf and Clayton Kershaw likely will start four of the first six games, if necessary. The Dodgers' bullpen also features two quality left-handers, Hong-Chi Kuo and George Sherrill.
Why, then, do I like the Phillies?

No idea.

1. Cliff Lee:
The Dodgers wanted him before the July 31 non-waiver deadline.

Instead, the Phillies got him. Lee will not be available until Game 3, but he is again on a roll, posting a 1.10 ERA in his two starts in the Division Series. Kershaw, the only Dodgers starter comparable to Lee, is not as mature a pitcher at age 21 and does not pitch as deep into games.

We could judge the two off of their age and how well Lee has pitched in his last two starts. Or we could judge it off an entire season. A season that saw Kershaw throw for a lower ERA, strike out more batters, and give up fewer home runs than Lee. But that would make too much sense.

Hamels, inconsistent all season, is difficult to trust in Game 1, but I would take Phillies right-hander Joe Blanton and lefty J.A. Happ over every Dodgers starter but Kershaw. Righty Hiroki Kuroda, recovering from a herniated disk in his neck, is a physical question.

Team ERA's: Phillies 4.16, Dodgers 3.41
Team WHIP: Phillies 1.35 Dodgers 1.25
Team Opponents BA: Phillies .265 Dodgers .233
Team K/9: Phillies 7.13 Dodgers 7.77
Team H/9: Phillies 9.14 Dodgers 7.73

Righty Vicente Padilla, who dominated the dazed Cardinals in Game 3 of the Division Series, might get too wound up trying to defeat his former team.

Let's just ignore the fact that in his first 8 games as a Dodger Padilla allowed only 14 runs and pitched to a 3.20 ERA, and focus on the fact that he might possibly play bad against his old team. A team he hasn't played with since 2005.


Let's face it, the Dodgers overcame the Cardinals' rotation edge in large part because left fielder Matt Holliday dropped a flyball. The Dodgers are less likely to derive such benefit from a random occurrence in a best-of-7 series.

After the error by Holliday, do you know how many more batters the Dodgers needed to win the game? FOUR! If Casey Blake or Ronnie Belliard fail to get on base, the Cardinals win. If either Russell Martin or Mark Loretta fail to get on base, they go to extra innings. With all of those possible outs, how can the series loss for the Cardinals be pinned on the guy?

2. The Phillies' offensive awakening: The Phillies were flat offensively going into the postseason, and in some ways, they still are.

If they still are flat, how is that an awakening? Wouldn't that be more like a hangover?

Rollins, their leadoff man, had two huge ninth-inning hits against the Rockies but went just 5-for-19 with no walks overall.

He had two clutch hits and only managed to hit .263 as a lead-off hitter. You do realize, that you don't have to mention everyone right?

Not to worry:
Virtually every other Phillies hitter — Utley, Howard, Ibanez, Jayson Werth and Shane Victorino — got hot in the Division Series. Intangibles often are overrated, but at this point, can anyone doubt the Phillies' toughness or their ability to seize the moment?

And I thought you were going to use actual information that would help prove your point; like who had the better team batting average or the higher on-base percentage. But, yeah, toughness is always a key factor in who wins the series.

3. The Phillies' mix-and-match bullpen
A thing of beauty, it isn't. But Lidge's struggles, in a sense, have liberated manager Charlie Manuel. Rather than rely on an unreliable Lidge as his sole closer, Manuel will continue playing matchups, using lefty Scott Eyre, righty Ryan Madson and heaven knows who else in the late innings.

Good for Charlie. It was nice that Lidge was so inconsistent that it forced allowed him to play around with his bullpen lineup. He switched it up so much, it's back to being the same exact lineup.

OK, now for my final qualifier:....... It's baseball. It's October. Who the heck knows how a series might turn out between such evenly matched clubs? I'm going with my instincts.

Ken, let me remind you that last year, your instincts led you to pick both the Dodgers and Rays over the Phillies.


Phillies in 7.

Okay, let me get this straight. At the end of the season, the Phillies looked bad and the Rockies were rolling, so you picked Colorado. Now that the Phillies are playing well, you're picking them. Even though all of the things that made you worry about the Phillies are more than likely to come up in a seven game series. Lidge struggled all season, but he played awesome on Monday night, so he must be back. Rollins stunk all season and most of the series, but came up huge late in the game, so he too, must be back. These factors along with Cliff Lee, the offensive awakening, and the bullpen led you to pick the Phillies. All the while, dismissing the fact that the Dodgers have led the NL the entire season, won the season series between the two clubs, have home-field advantage, have more rest, have the lower ERA, have the higher batting average, have the higher OBP, and the better bullpen.Yeah that seems about right.

Point / Counterpoint: Rick Reilly on Michael Jordan

September 17, 2009

This is our column where we wrangle every nonsensical statement a writer proclaims in their commentary. Next up is Rick Reilly of ESPN, taken from his article titled "Be Like Mike? No Thanks"

Michael Jordan's Hall of Fame talk was the Exxon Valdez of speeches. It was, by turns, rude, vindictive and flammable. And that was just when he was trying to be funny. It was tactless, egotistical and unbecoming. When it was done, nobody wanted to be like Mike.

You see what he did there? He referenced an oil spill of the early 90's, saying that his speech was on the same level of atrociousness. Or is it because he thinks Jordan's speech was caused by alcohol and in-turn killed baby seals?

And yet we couldn't stop watching. Because this was an inside look into the mindset of an icon who'd never let anybody inside before. From what I saw, I'd never want to go back. Here is a man who's won just about everything there is to win -- six NBA titles, five MVPs and two Olympics golds. And yet he sounded like a guy who's been screwed out of every trophy ever minted. He's the world's first sore winner.

This was his chance to ask all of the people who have ever doubted him "How you like me, now?" And I am not going to fault him for it, his whole career was built on proving people wrong. This is the same guy who was relegated to JV as a sophomore and made it his mission to prove that coach wrong for the rest of his life. Without his ability to use that disapproval as motivation, we wouldn't have witnessed the greatness he displayed on the court.

In the entire 23-minute cringe-athon, there were only six thank yous, seven if you count his sarcastic rip at the very Hall that was inducting him. "Thank you, Hall of Fame, for raising ticket prices, I guess," he sneered. By comparison, David Robinson's classy and heartfelt seven-minute speech had 17. Joe Montana's even shorter speech in Canton had 23. Who wrote your speech Mike? Kanye West?

Is there a minimum number of thank yous needed for a speech? Is this Chotchkys? Did he need more flair? And Kanye doesn't write acceptance speeches, he interrupts them. So if you're going to use Kanye as a reference, use it correctly. Go with something like this: It was really a surprise when Stockton's speech was interrupted by Kanye West, where he jumped up onstage and proclaimed "Yo, John, I'm really happy you were inducted and Imma let you finish here soon, but I just wanna tell you how I'm feeling, gotta make you understand that Jordan and Pippen were the best of all-time." Turns out, he only did it at the request of Michael. See that makes sense, but you obviously didn't think this through.

Not that Jordan's speech wasn't from the heart. It was. It's just that Jordan's heart on this night could give you frostbite. Nobody was spared, including his high school coach, his high school teammate, his college coach, two of his pro coaches, his college roommate, his pro owner, his pro general manager, the man who was presenting him that evening, even his kids!

"I wouldn't want to be you guys if I had to," he said as they squirmed in their seats.

What's wrong with him saying that? His kids have to follow in his footsteps. Can you imagine trying to live up to his larger than life shadow? It would be a tough task for anyone, and you should give Michael credit, for understanding how hard it must be and for acknowledging that their life is not an easy one.

He even mocked his own brothers, calling them maybe 5-foot-5 and 5-6. Actually, they're about 5-8 and 5-9. Michael was the one blessed with the height gene, not the tact one.

I didn't know you got tact from your gene pool. I figured it was something ingrained in you by influential people in your life, like, I don't know, your coaches. Also, what brothers don't joke on one another?

Jordan had decided that this was the perfect night to list all the ways everybody sitting in front of him had pissed him off over the past 30 years: Dean Smith, Doug Collins, Jerry Reinsdorf, Pat Riley, Isiah Thomas, Larry Bird, Magic Johnson, George Gervin and Jeff Van Gundy. It was the only one-man roast in Hall of Fame history. Only very little of it was funny.

I guess you missed Bob Cousy's induction where he said "George Mikan is to basketball what Bette Davis is to basketball." And that was after he motioned to Red Auerbach and said "I've seen younger faces on cash."

He was like that Japanese World War II soldier they found hiding in a cave in Guam 27 years after the Japanese surrendered. The only difference is, Jordan won! What good is victory if you never realize the battle is over?

The Japanese solider was just doing what he thought was his duty, couldn't we assume the same about Jordan?

This is how Jordan really is, I just never thought he'd let the world see it. His old Bulls' assistant coach, Johnny Bach, told me early on, "This guy is a killer. He's a cold-blooded assassin. It's not enough for him to beat you. He wants you dead."

Rick, I am guessing you didn't spend much time as an athlete. You see, coaches use military terms to describe players all-the-time. This is why, Kellen Winslow Jr. proclaimed he was a soldier, and Kevin Garnett says he's bringing his AK to the arena. It's also why I was confused when everyone attacked him for talking about being "said" solider. Coaches always compare games to war, and they never get any criticism for their words. This double standard doesn't make much sense. If playing a game is made akin to fighting a war, then Jordan played his part.

I covered his entire career and saw examples of it throughout. Saw him break Rodney McCray in after-practice, $100 shooting games, humiliate him until McCray lost his stroke. Watched him race his car up the shoulder of Chicago interstates just because he didn't have the patience to wait in traffic. Heard how he'd kept his friends confined to his hotel room at the Barcelona Olympics so he could play cards -- and keep playing until he won. For Jordan, it was never enough to win. He had to have scalps.

If it was so well-known that he didn't let others go until he won, shouldn't they be blamed for gambling with him in the first place? No one was forced to play cards with Jordan. People believe in free will, and, on the flip side, if one doesn't believe in free will, then Jordan was the best example of manifest destiny since the United States expanded westward.


Now here he was, in Springfield without a filter or a PR guy to cut him off, while his staff must've been covering their eyes. And suddenly, it hit you: Michael Jordan is the guy who gets up at the rehearsal dinner, grabs the mike and ruins the night.

How did he ruin the night? Had this not happened, you wouldn't be talking about it a week later. If anything, he made it more memorable. Sure, there would have been highlight clips played and articles of his greatness published. But it wouldn't have been a story without him opening up and telling everyone what he thought. And if anything, his staff should be pissed he didn't save this for a book and done the talk show circuit. At least Jordan was man enough to say all he had to say to everyone's faces, as opposed to the hundreds of athletes who air their grievances from bookshelves.

The thing Jordan doesn't understand is, it doesn't have to be this way. Terry Bradshaw won four Super Bowls and gave one of the greatest speeches in the history of the Hall of Fame. "Folks!" he hollered. "You don't get elected into the Hall of Fame by yourself! Thank you number 88, Lynn Swann! Thank you, Franco Harris! Thank you Rocky Bleier! What I wouldn't give right now to put my hands under [center] Mike Webster's butt just one more time! Thank you Mike!" He thanked linemen, tight ends, everybody but the ushers.

He also thanked steroids, oh wait, that was Steve Courson.

Had Jordan been in his shoes, he'd have said, "Hey, Steve Kerr! Remember when I kicked your ass in that fight?"

Actually, Jordan was in his shoes, and he didn't say that.


Jordan owes a roomful of apologies. But it'll never happen. I know firsthand.

Oh, really? Go on.

Before his second comeback -- with the Washington Wizards --

That is so thoughtful of you. I had totally forgotten that he played for the Wizards.

I was the first out with the story by a month.

Let me guess they denied it.

Jordan and his agent, David Falk, denied it, said I was crazy, practically said I was smoking something. Then, after a month of lies, Jordan admitted it was all true. I saw him in the locker room before his first game back and said, "You wanna say something to me, maybe?"

So you told him to give you an apology for denying something that wasn't cemented yet and had nothing to do with you. Who owes who, an apology?

And he said, "You know you don't get no apologies in this business."

So I wouldn't hold your breath.

Bitter, much? This happened in 2001. Get. Over. It. Athletes deny things like this all the time. Here is an example, and another, and another. Or are you upset Jordan didn't call you out in his speech too, Rick?

They called it an "acceptance" speech, but the last thing Jordan seems to be able to do is accept it's over. In fact, Jordan hinted that he might make yet another comeback at 50.

That would be awesome if he came back, let's just hope he doesn't make a speech.

I just hope Comeback No. 3 doesn't come with a speech.

I just said that.

Because then I'm really screwed.

In closing, Rick Reilly thinks it was wrong of Jordan to share his unique viewpoint on his own career and that tact is something you are either born with or without. We also had to wait almost the entire column to understand the real reason Reilly is criticizing Michael, a grudge that he has been holding for almost a decade because Jordan denied giving him a scoop. When Reilly gets inducted to the Sports Writers Hall of Fame, he plans on flying Jordan out firsthand to thank him for the extra incentive to succeed.

Point/Counterpoint: Jason Whitlock on Rick Pitino

August 14, 2009

This is our newest column where we wrangle every nonsensical statement a writer proclaims in their commentary. Our next victim is none other than Jason Whitlock, taken from the article titled "Pitino ran into the biggest dynasty in sports":

The '72 Dolphins can't touch Pussy Galore.

Wow, nice reference, way to stay current, Jason.

Adding Rick Pitino, Josh Hamilton and Reggie Miller to her list of victims, Pussy Galore's record remains unblemished and unprecedentedly gaudy since the beginning of the decade when A.C. Green escaped the NBA untainted by her joys.

Pitino is a victim of his own arrogance, not Pussy Galore's wickedness. Let me remind you that Pitino had sex with Mrs. Sypher on the floor of a restaurant. Now, that's class. Josh Hamilton is a victim due to his addiction, not Pussy Galore's wickedness. Reggie Miller is single and has no respect for the sanctity of marriage, but he is no victim.

Reportedly, she's set her sights on Tim Tebow, vowing to bring down the allegedly still-celibate Heisman Trophy-winning quarterback before the BCS title game.
Is there a logical reason to believe she won't succeed?


Are you honestly doubting Tim Tebow's reserve?

She impeached a president and now, more impressively, she threatens to topple a highly successful college basketball coach. As my mother would say, she's a bitch on a bicycle. Respect her and her power or risk experiencing her wrath.
Pitino should've coughed up the $10 million. His reputation will never recover.


Hush-hush money, huh? How about not cheating on your wife? It's much cheaper.

Seriously, I don't want to make excuses for Pitino. I don't want to rationalize his gross error, but you know damn well Pussy Galore's BFF (booze) played a major role in this fiasco. This sounds like the mother of all Patron body shots that skidded way off course.

Apparently, alcohol is just as vindictive as Pussy Galore. But, Jason, it wasn't alcohol's fault, it was the terrorists' fault.

Look, the adultery is bad. His $3,000 bribe/health care package is worse. But those, along with his Catholicism, are private matters properly left between Pitino and his wife and family. Louisville should not use some sort of flimsy morality clause to get rid of Pitino.

Whitlock, be honest, you know what it's like to be in a restaurant after hours and leave with a $3,000 plumbing bill.

He is no more immoral than Hamilton and Miller, PG's other recent victims.

Really? A man who invoked 9/11, paid for an abortion while trying to cover up his misdeeds, and denied all of the accusations until it was too late is no more immoral than Josh Hamilton and Reggie Miller. Really?

I know, Hamilton blamed his fall off the wagon on his addiction to alcohol and drugs. The Deadspin pictures told a far different story. Drunken actions are sober thoughts. The groping, licking and backdooring revealed a man using the bottle as an excuse to reconnect with the real love of his life, Strange Tang.


Strange Tang, I was just getting used to Pussy Galore. Also, how do Honey Ryder, Alotta Fagina, and Sylvia Trench fit into this equation?


And just as Hamilton should thank Pitino for diverting attention away from his defeat, Reggie Miller can thank Hamilton for overshadowing his text-message pursuit of a 25-year-old clothing designer with a crazy, rich and vindictive fiance.

Do you really believe that? The Hamilton story died because he confronted the pictures honestly, not because Pitino's abortion story overshadowed his moment of weakness. And why even bring up Reggie? Do you honestly think flirting over the phone is on par with Pitino?

Just think about that and ask yourself if there is a more powerful force on this planet than Pussy Galore.

Tim Tebow..? The power of love? Polka power?

I'm sure some of you reading this are appalled that I won't pass harsh judgment on Pitino's transgression. You're making the same mistake made by the hypocritical South Carolina governor who voted to impeach President Clinton.
Or you play for a team that never schedules Pussy Galore as an opponent.

In summation, Pussy Galore has never lost in an effort to take down athletes, celebrities, or everyday people like you and me. Pitino, Hamilton, and Reggie are all victims of her enchantment. Pitino's story should be private, even though he is a public figure and coaches young men on and off the court. Tim Tebow will be taken down shortly, even though he has devoted his entire life to Christ. Hamilton and Reggie should be thankful for Pitino's misdeeds, even though Hambone's story was dead before the Pitino story broke and Reggie didn't really do anything wrong. Lastly, if you don't agree with anything Jason said, you're a hypocrite and/or gay.

Point / Counterpoint

August 3, 2009

This is our newest column where we counterpoint every nonsensical statement a writer proclaims in their commentary. Our first victim is none other than John Clayton, taken from the article titled "Packers ready to follow Rodgers' lead":

First of all the title is idiotic. Weren't they following his lead last year? When the entire organization backed him over their former and future HOF QB.

With no Brett Favre
distractions this summer, the Green Bay Packers feel young, fresh and optimistic about the 2009 season.

What team isn't fresh and optimistic in early August? Last summer the Lions were talking about going to the playoffs.

There is no question that this is Rodgers' team now that the books are finally closed on Favre.

Um, when was their a question that this was Rodgers' team? Once again they chose him over Favre. That's why he was traded.

Rodgers showed Favre-like toughness last season, playing through a second-degree separation of his right shoulder without missing a start.

You see playing hurt at the quarterback position is rarely done. Wait I forgot about Philip Rivers, Peyton Manning, Steve McNair, Ben Roethlisberger, Byron Leftwich, Steve Young.

Seeing nose tackle Ryan Pickett smiling and joking around in defensive line drills caught me off guard. At 29, Pickett is making a career change from being a 4-3 defensive tackle to a nose tackle in the Packers' new 4-3. That's a position switch that usually turns veterans surly and resistant.

You see, I expect all veteran players going through change to be furious about coming in and getting highly paid to play a game. But this Ryan Pickett actually likes his job, ain't that a hoot?


Dom Capers has enough linebackers to run a 3-4 defense that can pressure the quarterback. The longtime NFL defensive coordinator, entering his first season with the Packers, has been a master of finding outside pass-rushers.In Green Bay, he has at least three options on the outside: Aaron Kampman, Jeremy Thompson, and Clay Matthews.

A master of finding outside pass-rushers? John, you do realize he is not the GM. That would be Ted Thompson, and he is the guy who drafted these players. Also out of the three, two of them were on the Packers last year. And as you noted Dom wasn't.

The most interesting development on offense is how Jermichael Finley is emerging at tight end. Donald Lee is clearly the starter, but Finley is a 6-foot-5, 247-pound target who might be able to expand the passing offense out of two-TE sets.

Preposterous! A second year player at training camp who looks like he has improved. Typically, after they adjust to the rigors of the NFL and understand how much they need to train and prepare, they get worse. But not Jermichael Finley, who won't take Lee's spot as a starter, he is special.

It's pretty clear the offensive line is in transition. Right tackle Mark Tauscher wasn't re-signed.

Tauscher probably wasn't re-signed because he tore his ACL in December. Why would any team pay someone that might not be healthy this season? And that's before you find out if he can even still play.

Left tackle Chad Clifton is on the sidelines recovering from arthroscopic surgeries to both shoulders and both knees. And center Scott Wells is being challenged by Jason Spitz for the starting job.

Thompson has drafted enough mid-round players who have the bodies to fit the job descriptions, but the key to camp is settling on a starting offensive line. Clifton should be fine. How guards Josh Sitton and Allen Barbre fare could be the key to the success of the running game and pass-blocking.

That is quite the transition. One player was let go, and he won't be able to play. Another player is hurt, but he will be ready to play. Another player is being challenged by another. And two starting lineman will be a big key in how effective the offense is going to play. Amazing!

So in summation; the Packers feel fresh and invigorated after the offseason, Aaron Rodgers is finally their leader, Jermichael Finley has surprisingly improved but not enough to start, Dom Capers is a master, and the o-line is in transition because one guy wasn't re-signed. Wow, thanks John Clayton!
 

© 2008-2010 ·The Lawn Chair Boys by TNB